Sukkah 45b Part 4/5

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

When does the bracha on lulav or sukkah come again each day? Shmuel and Rabbi Yochanan hold opposite views, and a beraisa challenges Rabbi Yochanan on both. For sukkah the answer is a machlokes Tannaim over tefillin taken off and put back on, and the Gemara follows Rebbi. The Mishnah Berurah has a new bracha according to everybody after the bathroom.

Key points

• Shmuel gives lulav a bracha every day and sukkah only one, since night continues sukkah.
• The beraisa's daily bracha on lulav speaks of the Beis HaMikdash, answering the kasha on Rabbi Yochanan.
• For sukkah, Rabbi Yochanan follows Rebbi, who has a new bracha each time tefillin go on.
• In the Gemara, Abaye and Rava both rule like Rebbi, so each hefsek brings a new bracha.
• Against the Mechaber, the Rama has no new bracha on tefillin removed to put right back on.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Shmuel and Rabbi Yochanan on brachos
2. 5:07The beraisa's kashas on Rabbi Yochanan
3. 8:45Question about Shemini Atzeres
4. 9:32Lulav in the Beis HaMikdash
5. 12:26Machlokes Tannaim on tefillin brachos
6. 16:40Abaye and Rava on the halacha
7. 17:04Background of Rav Mari
8. 21:35Shulchan Aruch on removing tefillin

Topics

• Lulav
• Leishev BaSukkah
• Tefillin
• Hefsek