Sukkah 56a Part 2/6

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

At kiddush in the sukkah, with both leishev basukkah and shehecheyanu to say, which bracha comes first? Rav puts sukkah first because the chiyuv of the day comes first, and Rabbah bar bar Chana puts zman first because it comes more often. The Gemara asks whether they follow Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel on Shabbos kiddush, then ties their machlokes to Tannaim on a Mishnah about Shavuos falling on Shabbos.

Key points

• On Shabbos kiddush, Beis Shammai puts the day first, since Shabbos brings the need for wine.
• In the Gemara, Rav can agree with Beis Hillel, since leishev basukkah stands without shehecheyanu.
• The Gemara matches Rav and Rabbah bar bar Chana's dispute to Abba Shaul and the Mishnah's Tanna.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Rav and Rabbah bar bar Chana reviewed
2. 1:36Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel on kiddush
3. 5:02Linking the machlokes to Beis Shammai
4. 7:32Rav and Beis Hillel's first reason
5. 10:59The Mishnah of Shavuos on Shabbos
6. 13:33Abba Shaul and the Mishnah's Tanna

Topics

• Leishev BaSukkah
• Shehecheyanu
• Kiddush
• Tadir