Sukkah 50b Part 6/9

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does the music of the Beis HaMikdash override Shabbos, and where is the machlokes? Rav Yosef puts it on shir shel korban, and Rav Yirmiyah bar Abba on shir shel sho'eva, a simcha yeseira beyond the avodah. A beraisa, and then the Mishnah's chalil, leave Rav Yosef with kashas he cannot answer. The bottom line is that shir shel korban is docheh Shabbos according to all, and the machlokes is on shir shel sho'eva.

Key points

• Rav Yosef puts the machlokes on shir shel korban, and Rav Yirmiyah bar Abba puts it on shir shel sho'eva.
• A beraisa with a machlokes on shir shel sho'eva raises two kashas on Rav Yosef.
• The beraisa highlights shir shel sho'eva to show the lenient Tanna's strength, since koach d'heteira adif.
• The Gemara forbids instruments on Shabbos, as an issur d'Rabbanan, in case one comes to fix them.
• In the end Rav Yosef is refuted, and shir shel korban is docheh Shabbos according to all.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Rav Yosef and Rav Yirmiyah bar Abba
2. 2:47The beraisa's kasha on Rav Yosef
3. 5:28A second kasha from the beraisa
4. 8:01Rav Yosef answers the second kasha
5. 10:23Koach d'heteira adif
6. 12:27Musical instruments on Shabbos
7. 15:36The Mishnah's chalil and its Tanna
8. 20:03Bottom line of the sugya

Topics

• Shir Shel Korban
• Simchas Beis HaSho'eva
• Docheh Shabbos