Sukkah 54a Part 3/5

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

How can the Mishnah put the most blowings of the chatzotzros at 48, on Erev Shabbos of the Chag, if every musaf gets its own nine? Rav Zeira and Rava each work out the count for Shabbos of the Chag, and Rava leaves out the twelve blowings of milui hamayim. Rosh Hashanah on Shabbos and Erev Pesach also come to 48. The rule of tana v'shayer explains why the Tanna names only one of them.

Key points

• An extra word in the beraisa teaches that each musaf gets its own nine tekiyos.
• Rava explains that the twelve blowings of milui hamayim are not blown on Shabbos.
• The Gemara prefers Erev Shabbos of the Chag for its chiddush of blowing by the mizbeach.
• Under tana v'shayer, the Tanna leaves cases out only when more than one remains.
• Erev Pesach also comes to 48, with blowing before three Hallels for each of three groups.

In this shiur

1. 0:00The beraisa on blowing for each musaf
2. 1:12Rav Zeira on Shabbos of the Chag
3. 2:17Rava's two kashas on Rav Zeira
4. 5:23Rava and the blowings of milui hamayim
5. 8:16Rosh Hashanah on Shabbos and its musafim
6. 14:54The rule of tana v'shayer
7. 20:37Erev Pesach and its Hallels
8. 25:06Going back over Rava's count

Topics

• Chatzotzros
• Musaf
• Tana V'Shayer
• Karban Pesach