Rosh Hashanah 32a Part 2/6

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Where does malchiyos belong in the Rosh Hashanah Shemoneh Esrei, and is shofar blown with it? Rabbi Akiva and the Tanna who disputes with him in the Mishnah disagree on both points. The Gemara then finds a pasuk for each bracha. Rebbi learns malchiyos from pesukim placed next to each other, and another Tanna learns it from the chatzotzros.

Key points

• The Mishnah's machlokes has two points: where malchiyos is said, and whether shofar is blown with it.
• In the Gemara, malchiyos said without shofar gets nine pesukim instead of ten, and Rashi gives no reason that settles it.
• The Gemara learns the first brachos of Shemoneh Esrei from a pasuk that we also say in Hodu.
• The Gemara's binyan av from the chatzotzros puts malchiyos with zichronos wherever zichronos is said.
• The Gemara brings two views on whether kedushas hayom goes fourth or in the middle, which raises a chakira.

In this shiur

1. 0:00The Mishnah on malchiyos and shofar
2. 3:56Rabbi Akiva's challenge and nine pesukim
3. 5:40Why Rashi does not explain
4. 8:19Pesukim for the Shemoneh Esrei brachos
5. 9:59Shabbason and mikra kodesh
6. 12:55Rebbi's source for malchiyos
7. 16:50Binyan av from the chatzotzros
8. 25:05Where kedushas hayom goes

Topics

• Malchiyos
• Zichronos
• Rosh Hashanah
• Shemoneh Esrei