Sukkah 47b Part 3/4

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does Rabbi Yehuda hold that Shemini Atzeres requires lina? The Gemara reads the pasuk's exclusion of lina as covering only Pesach Sheini, and brings the Mishnah in Bikkurim, which requires tenufa and lina, as Rabbi Yehuda's. Tenufa for bikkurim is not explicit in the pasuk, so not everyone holds it, much like a gezeira shava that needs a kabbalah from one's Rebbi. Then another Tanna who also requires tenufa puts the proof in doubt.

Key points

• The exclusion from the pasuk on lina covers only Pesach Sheini, a korban Pesach like it.
• Bikkurim needing tenufa marks the Mishnah as Rabbi Yehuda's, so lina needs no six-day Yom Tov.
• The Gemara suggests the Mishnah is perhaps another Tanna's, one who also requires tenufa.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Rabbi Yehuda and lina on Shemini Atzeres
2. 1:25The pasuk excluding lina
3. 2:49The Mishnah in Bikkurim
4. 4:44Beraisa on tenufa for bikkurim
5. 7:08Why tenufa is not universal
6. 8:20Another Tanna who requires tenufa

Topics

• Shemini Atzeres
• Lina
• Bikkurim
• Tenufa