Sukkah 47b Part 2/4

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does Rabbi Yehuda hold that Shemini Atzeres requires lina? His beraisa ties lina to the six days of Yom Tov, and the Gemara answers that it excludes only Pesach Sheini. The Gemara supports this from an unnamed Mishnah in Bikurim that requires tenufa and lina. Then the Gemara suggests another Tanna, who also holds there is a mitzvah of tenufa by Bikurim, as the Mishnah's author, and the support is knocked out.

Key points

• The Gemara asks why Rabbi Yehuda's beraisa seems to exempt Shemini Atzeres from lina.
• The Gemara answers that the beraisa excludes only Pesach Sheini, which is similar to Pesach Rishon.
• The Gemara's proof: an unnamed Mishnah requires tenufa and lina for Bikurim, a one-day event.
• Rabbi Yehuda learns tenufa for Bikurim from the basket being put down a second time.
• Through a gezeira shava of yad from shlamim, the other Tanna has kohen and owner waving together.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Rabbi Yehuda's contradiction on lina
2. 2:22The answer: Pesach Sheini
3. 3:41Hachi nami mistabra from Bikurim
4. 8:05Tenufa in the pesukim of Bikurim
5. 12:05Rashi in Chumash on tenufa
6. 13:06Perhaps another Tanna authored it
7. 15:41The gezeira shava of yad
8. 21:09Reviewing the Gemara inside

Topics

• Lina
• Bikurim
• Tenufa
• Pesach Sheini