Sukkah 47b Part 1/4

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does Rabbi Yehuda, who counts lina among what makes Shemini Atzeres a regel bifnei atzmo, contradict his own beraisa? That beraisa learns from a hekesh in Parshas Re'eh that Pesach Sheni has no lina. The Gemara answers that the hekesh excludes only Pesach Sheni, which is like Pesach Rishon. Support comes from a stam Mishnah in Bikurim that lists lina, whose mention of tenufa points to Rabbi Yehuda as its Tanna.

Key points

• Rashi reads uvishalta in the pasuk of the Karban Pesach as roasting, tzli esh.
• Getting up in the morning after the Karban Pesach points to a mitzvah of lina, sleeping over.
• Rabbi Yehuda's beraisa exempts Pesach Sheni from lina through a hekesh to six days of matzah.
• The Gemara limits the hekesh to Pesach Sheni, which is similar to Pesach Rishon, not Shemini Atzeres.
• A stam Mishnah in Bikurim lists lina, and its tenufa points to Rabbi Yehuda as its Tanna.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Shemini Atzeres as a regel bifnei atzmo
2. 2:00The pasuk in Re'eh and lina
3. 4:35Question on sleeping Pesach night
4. 6:26The Gemara's question on Rabbi Yehuda
5. 10:33Excluding Shemini Atzeres from lina too?
6. 14:47The Mishnah in Bikurim
7. 17:05The shir sung with Bikurim
8. 28:43Reading the sugya inside again

Topics

• Lina
• Shemini Atzeres
• Pesach Sheni
• Bikurim