Sukkah 49a Part 2/3

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does wine poured into the shitin still carry milah? A beraisa holds the wine stayed in a space by the mizbeach, and every seventy years it was burned in the Azara. The Gemara asks whose view the Mishnah of no milah follows, and answers in two versions. One rests on wine that got caught on the way down, the other on the rule that a thing whose mitzvah is done has no milah.

Key points

• According to a beraisa, young kohanim gathered the congealed wine every seventy years and burned it.
• Ravina learns the burning from nosar through a gezeira shava on the word kodesh.
• Ein mo'alin bahem means there is no chiyuv milah, not that personal use is allowed.
• The Gemara answers the Mishnah can fit even the Rabbanan, where the wine got caught going down.
• Nothing whose mitzvah is done carries milah, and Rashi calls the pouring the ikar mitzvah.

In this shiur

1. 0:00The beraisa on the shitin
2. 2:21Ravina's gezeira shava from nosar
3. 5:40What milah means
4. 7:15The Mishnah on nesachim and milah
5. 14:19Wine that got caught
6. 15:31The second version of the sugya
7. 19:26Rashi on the ikar mitzvah
8. 20:46Chazara of the sugya

Topics

• Shitin
• Milah
• Nisuch HaYayin
• Gezeira Shava