Sukkah 50b Part 3/9

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Is the machlokes over a wooden kli shareis really tied to whether ikar shira is b'kli or b'peh? The Gemara says no. The machlokes turns on how the pasuk of the menorah is darshened. Rebbi darshens klal u'prat u'klal and leaves out wood, while Rabbi Yosi bar Rabbi Yehuda darshens ribui u'miut and leaves out only earthenware.

Key points

• Rav Yosef ties the chalil machlokes to whether ikar shira, an avodah docheh Shabbos, is b'kli.
• The Gemara answers that perhaps everyone holds ikar shira b'peh, or that possible is not learned from impossible.
• Rebbi's klal u'prat u'klal on the menorah includes metals like gold but leaves out wood.
• Ribui u'miut already includes metals at the miut and, at the end, excludes only earthenware.
• The Bnei Yissaschar reads Mordechai's lineage as klal u'prat u'klal, the sixth mida, matching v'rav chesed.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Chalil on Shabbos and ikar shira
2. 1:16A wooden kli shareis
3. 3:47The Gemara separates the two machlokesin
4. 7:34Klal u'prat and the thirteen midos
5. 11:56Rebbi's klal u'prat u'klal on the menorah
6. 15:49Ribui u'miut and the menorah
7. 23:38Bnei Yissaschar on the thirteen midos
8. 29:37Back to the wooden menorah

Topics

• Klal U'Prat U'Klal
• Ribui U'Miut
• Menorah