Sukkah 50b Part 1/9

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Does the chalil played with the korban push aside Shabbos? Rav Yosef says it depends on whether the main part of the shira is the instrument or the singing. Rav Yosef links this to a beraisa on klei shareis made of wood, with the wooden Abuv of Moshe as the model. The Gemara replies that perhaps everyone holds the instrument is the main part.

Key points

• Rav Yosef puts the machlokes in the shira of the korban, not the Simchas Beis HaShoeivah.
• For Rabbi Yosi bar Rabbi Yehuda the instrument is the main part, so the chalil is avodah and pushes aside Shabbos.
• The Gemara tells of the wooden Abuv of Moshe, whose sound suffered once it was coated in gold.
• Rav Yosef ties the dispute over wooden klei shareis to the dispute over the chalil.
• The Gemara suggests that perhaps the wooden klei shareis dispute is about learning possible from impossible.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Does the chalil push aside Shabbos
2. 2:28Rav Yosef: instrument or singing
3. 5:45The Abuv of Moshe
4. 7:57Beraisa on wooden klei shareis
5. 18:37Question on a cappella music
6. 19:54Learning possible from impossible
7. 23:52Mashal of davening in English
8. 26:11Review of the Gemara

Topics

• Shira Shel Korban
• Klei Shareis
• Chalil
• Avodah on Shabbos