Sukkah 50a Part 2/3

AI summary (may contain mistakes)

Was the Mishnah's simcha called beis hasho'eiva or beis hachashuva? She'eiva fits the pasuk about drawing water with sason, and chashuva fits Rav Nachman, that the shisin go back to the six days of creation. A beraisa then argues whether the chalil is docheh Shabbos. In the Gemara's end, the simcha of beis hasho'eiva, a simcha yeseira in the girsa on the side, is not docheh Shabbos.

Key points

• Neither reading, she'eiva nor chashuva, is a mistake in its meaning, the Gemara says.
• The wine also reached the shisin, perhaps only through the water's cry to be close to Hashem.
• Rav Yosef ties the machlokes to whether the main shira is the instrument or the mouth.

In this shiur

1. 0:00Review of the Mishnah of the chalil
2. 1:34She'eiva or chashuva
3. 4:45A question about the wine
4. 5:56Beraisa: is the chalil docheh Shabbos
5. 11:06Rav Yosef on the shir shel korban
6. 14:34Simchas beis hasho'eiva as simcha yeseira
7. 14:56Review of the sugya
8. 16:58Reading the Gemara inside again

Topics

• Simchas Beis HaSho'eiva
• Chalil
• Docheh Shabbos
• Shir Shel Korban